The Tool Shed Blog

Email Marketing Myths: Expert Insights to Dispel Misunderstandings

Business owners strive to establish a meaningful dialogue with their desired audience. An efficient way of achieving this is through the application of best practices in email marketing. It provides the page to generate a conversation within your targeted community or demographics. The person creating an efficient email strategy—leveraging techniques such as segmentation, email design, and even experiments with the types of emails or their presentation—can gain a significant advantage. To enhance effectiveness, email marketers often harness the power of a reliable email service provider and versatile email marketing software, avoiding spam filters where possible.

Email marketing is not just an effective tool to grab attention but also a powerful channel for conveying your brand's mission within a guide of guidelines. What better way to do so than with personalized, branded messages delivered directly to your audience? Armed with the right words, a sense of your audience's needs and questions, and custom email templates, your email platform can transform into a leading advertising tool. This strategy reaches the 3.8 billion email users worldwide while maintaining commendable deliverability. These resources help in propelling your words into action, delivering your message with authenticity and as intended.

Some brands steer clear of email marketing to pursue alternative platforms like Facebook, Twitter, and other forums. They do so without comprehending the additional benefits of email marketing, like detailed email analytics that serve to refine strategies. To harness the full potential of email marketing, a cohesive team action involving marketing professionals, content creators, and email strategists is often required.

There are, however, rumors like “Email is dead” circulating the net, causing mass confusion about the power it holds for brand marketing.

Such misconceptions are hindering brands from boosting their conversion and retention rates. Approximately 80% of professionals are currently achieving success with email marketing – what’s the chance your competitors are as well? If you’re prepared to amplify your marketing approach and gain a competitive edge, then it’s time to debunk the myths surrounding email marketing and explore quintessential email marketing advice.

Let’s get started.

HubSpot Logo
Align Marketing and Sales with HubSpot
Break down silos and align your teams on one integrated platform. HubSpot's software solutions seamlessly connect your departmental data to help you create an exceptional customer experience. Click here to learn more about HubSpot.


We have to start with debunking this myth because it’s the most prevalent one whispered behind closed doors. It has even dissuaded some global marketing teams from incorporating email as a valid customer outreach tool in their advertising strategies.

1. Email Marketing is Dead

It’s hard to ignore the impact of email marketing when you look at the numbers. For instance, there is an astonishing $44 ROI for every dollar spent. Can you think of another marketing avenue that yields results like that?

This successful turnout could be in part due to the rise in email usage on mobile devices, which boasts a striking 68% email open rate. Those are impressive numbers for any email strategy.

When it comes to business marketing, it’s all about conversion rates at the end of the day. Irrespective of how many clicks and retweets your brand garners, if they're not translating into sales and sign-ups, then your efforts are likely fruitless.Unfortunately, a lot of brands are still mesmerized by the numbers behind social media. For example, there are over 2.2 billion Facebook users. The concept of reaching even a small percentage of this group seems astronomical. However, with a well-structured plan and the opportunities offered by advanced email marketing tools, you have the potential to harness valuable information that can redirect your marketing goal and approach.

2. Social Media Yields Better Conversions

When you look closer, you’ll see that email, with its strategic email content and design, trumps Facebook. One study shows internet users are twice as likely to open an email than to interact with your brand on social media. As a marketer, it's undeniable that email marketing, bolstered by implementing best-practices and conducting rigorous tests, outperforms search marketing, direct marketing, and other social platforms. The revenue it generates can add immense value to your business.

Referencing a plethora of available articles on the topic, some even witness email conversion rates 174% higher than social media. So why not tap into this highly effective marketing channel and see the benefits for your business? This isn't merely a critique of social media marketing - rather it serves to highlight how brand awareness can be enhanced by using social media and email marketing in tandem, while strategically leveraging segmentation, email templates, and the right keywords.

Imagine the number of conversions you'd achieve by integrating the analytics offered by various email providers and using that knowledge to continually refine your strategy through testing. News of some brands already capitalizing on these ideas, using social media to build their target email lists for their email marketing campaigns, is encouraging and serves as a testament to the power of combining different digital platforms.

No one enjoys receiving spam messages in their email inbox. However, email marketing has developed from its spammy roots, evolving into a medium that favors relevant, personalized content. In fact, the features of today's email platforms are designed with the reader in mind. A worthy article on this evolution of email marketing is definitely worth a read.

In the current landscape, marketing objectives are all about personalization and delivering the right content to the right audience. As part of this trend, consumers are increasingly opting in to receive emails from brands that specifically offer top-notch customer service.

Recipients don't merely want indiscriminate material sent to their inbox – they’re expecting to receive content that resonates with them. Utilizing email templates to craft personalized email content that suits the tastes and preferences of your subscribers can ensure your emails are well-received. To accomplish this goal, try to utilize short subject lines that are compelling and relevant.

3. Consumers Don’t Want More Emails (Especially Not from Brands!)

Studies indicate personalized emails receive 6x higher transaction rates. However, only 70% of brands are actually personalizing their email campaigns. This is a significant opportunity being overlooked, especially when using a robust email platform that allows for easy segmentation of audiences for personalized email marketing.

You can implement different strategies such as keeping track of purchases to segment your campaigns, thereby improving your messaging and making your emails more personalized for target audiences. Implementing these methods can lead to increased revenue and value for your business.

For instance, monitoring purchases allows you to recommend specific products or services. It’s also a great opportunity to segment your prospects, new clients, new customers, and loyal customers - making your marketing strategies more effective. Applying this information can massively aid in fine-tuning your email campaigns to deliver the optimal results.While the subject line you use can certainly influence email open rates and click rates, there's an even higher probability when the user recognizes the sender’s name, especially if they've been introduced to your brand through marketing campaigns on ecommerce platforms, or via SEO focused content on platforms like Instagram or your blog.

About 64% of subscribers open emails after seeing the sender’s image and name. This is followed by 47% of users who open emails based on the subject line. These metrics underline the importance of maintaining brand awareness and consistent messaging across all your business's platforms and landing pages.

Hence, it’s critical to display your company name as the sender. Coupled with special offers your brand might provide, recognition should aid in boosting your open rates and overall email engagement. Regular outreach through various marketing campaigns is essential to maintain brand recall.

Studies also reveal that it typically takes between seven to 13 touch points before a consumer converts. However, you must be aware of email frequency to avoid appearing spammy. Spammy emails are usually consigned to the spam folder, unread by anyone. Even in the face of email marketing myths, this reinforces the need for unique, non-spammy marketing strategies and a consistent messaging across platforms such as blogs or social media. Google-based research shows these changes in strategy can effectively drive customer engagement. Length of emails and touchpoints with prospects, from the initial email to the final conversion, can influence a client's interest in your marketing messages.

Boost revenue, productivity, and growth.
Explore The Gallery now.
Download Free Resources

 4. Subject Lines Impact Email Open Rates

What’s more telling is that adding the recipient’s name to the subject line further boosts email open rates by 18.3%. Utilizing tools like a campaign monitor or a CRM would be particularly beneficial in collecting and managing this data for you, making personalization more streamlined. Enhancements in AI (artificial intelligence) technology have made personalization, such as adding a subscribers name to an email, more efficient and effective.

Plenty of email marketing "recipes" are floating around on blogs and ecommerce websites, including tips on how to curate an effective newsletter. However, when the "ingredients" or elements involved don't invoke changes that generate the expected results, businesses often abandon their email campaigns. It's like throwing the whole email marketing pie out the window. But remember, crafting a relevant, concise, and spam-free email can enhance your open and reply rate significantly.

If you ask some marketers and brands, they'll tell you that automation software is too expensive and time-consuming. However, if incorporating automation into your email marketing strategy takes too long, then the issue could be the software, not the process itself or the email marketing myth that the length of emails is proportional to conversion.

Finding the right automation product is vital for streamlining your email marketing. With the proper tool, you could witness a considerable boost in your sales pipeline contribution - up to a 10% average increase according to research studies. These changes in email marketing strategies can directly affect your client base growth.

Email automation allows you to effectively segment and personalize your campaigns, enhancing conversions. You can use several AI services and products, including a link between automation and your email marketing process, to automate your marketing strategies. Update your landing pages to ensure they fully support these automated strategies and further encourage email engagement.Segmented campaigns can significantly enhance subscriber engagement, according to MailChimp. The deliberate practice of dividing your email list into segments and creating personalized content dramatically improves subscriber engagement and bolsters the sender reputation, which is crucial for email marketing success.

Again, countless "recipes" or strategies flood the internet, as well as numerous blog posts, claiming they can help brands cook up high-converting email campaigns. But, two common myths challenge this claim. Myth #1 posits that particular elements or "ingredients" guarantee success, and when they don't work, businesses are quick to abandon their email marketing entirely. Myth #2 is the misguided assumption that the length of the message or the inclusion of specific ingredients always translates to conversion. Understanding these myths can help you realize the true dynamics of email marketing success.

Debunking popular email marketing myths, like myth #1 and myth #2, is essential to driving a successful campaign. Research-based strategies aid in debunking these myths and promote an understanding that short marketing email subject lines, for instance, don’t necessarily work all the time. The effectiveness of a subject line varies across industries and specific brand needs. So, sometimes, a longer subject line might work better - it's not always about the number of characters.

5. Informational Content is What Your Subscribers Want

It’s commonly recommended that subject lines and titles be no more than 60 characters to increase email opens, but this rule isn't set in stone. It's an email marketing myth that may vary based on your client's preferences.

6. Email Automation Software is a Waste of Time & Money

In some cases, 61-70 characters in a subject line can even boost click-through rates. Ultimately, it comes down to understanding your industry, your target audience, and the type of topics that pique their interest. Leaning on AI and data-driven research, as well as revising your Google marketing strategy, can revamp your approach and tackle these email marketing myths head-on. A well-tested, carefully crafted, and skillfully worded email campaign can undoubtedly help capture the attention of your readers and maximize your performance. The power of using the right language, coupled with compelling CTAs (Calls to Action), cannot be underestimated.

Various surveys, charts, and infographics on platforms like LinkedIn and other websites suggest different optimal times for sending marketing emails - some advocate for Tuesdays, others for Thursdays; some suggest mornings, while others swear by the afternoon. These different viewpoints offer valuable examples to learn from and potentially model your own strategy after.

It's clear that there’s no one-size-fits-all answer to this question. This idea becomes more evident when you consider the fact that a marketing automation tool with integrated analytics can help decipher these different assertions and find the best time for your brand to send marketing messages. The problem with these philosophies is that they apply a one-size-fits-all approach, or a cookie-cutter approach, to email campaign tactics, treating all email subscribers worldwide identically. This is no different to the flawed approach witnessed in some B2B content marketing tactics. Think about your own habits; say, on LinkedIn. Some Mondays, for instance, you open promotional posts in the morning and others in the evening, a clear endorsement of how the uniformity of a text's timing can't guarantee its success.

People are humans, not robots. As a sender, understanding their habits and preferences is a must. Remember, a successful email campaign is a blend of meaningful segments, timely sends, and debunking email myths along the way. Practice, like in all business endeavors, will make perfect.

7. Shorter Email Subject Lines Get More Clicks

You also must factor in brands that follow these concepts to send emails simultaneously. This means your email, no matter how well-written and engaging the text, will get pushed down, making it less likely to be opened immediately (or any day after). This strategy and these email tactics are often elucidated more clearly in ebooks authored by experts in the field. A simple CTA at the end of your communication encouraging an immediate response might be a wise idea to combat this.

If this philosophy were accurate, you could place your ads in front of any audience and get tons of sales. However, we all know intuitively this isn't true. So why do we believe a single carefully crafted word, or a long list of email subscribers will boost ROI?

Sponsored by HubSpot

Even if you're getting high open rates from your low-quality leads, this doesn't mean it'll translate to a high conversion rate. Many experts corroborate this idea in their ebooks.

No email marketing campaign doesn't get unsubscribes. So if this were true, every brand, even companies involved in B2B, would be stumbling in the field of email marketing.

Of course, this isn't true.

What some brands find surprising is that unsubscribes are a good thing. Such instances provide examples to learn from, helping fine-tune your future email campaigns.

8. More Subscribes Equals Better ROI

No email marketing campaign doesn't get unsubscribes. So if this were true, every brand, even companies involved in B2B, would be stumbling in the field of email marketing.

Of course, this isn't true.

What some brands find surprising is that unsubscribes are a good thing. They're helping to clean up your email list, making it more efficient for your email marketing strategy. Why would you want subscribers to stick around if they're never going to become a customer?

9. Unsubscribes Mean Your Campaign’s Failing

These subscribers would only drive down your email campaign. When folks aren't opening your emails or clicking on your links in the email, then it impacts your analytics. By them unsubscribing, it helps save you time and effort weeding them out for a re-engagement campaign.

Just try not to go on a hiatus too long because when you return, your unsubscribe rate may increase once you try to reconnect.

Today, to effectively reach your readers, you should use all the channels you can to build an effective marketing strategy. Now that you see you have nothing to fear about email marketing, it's time to add it to your branding efforts.

You can generate more leads and sales with the right strategy and tools. If you'd like to learn more about making this happen for your brand, gardenpatch can help you take the next steps towards a successful email marketing campaign!

Learn how to make email marketing work for your business. Talk to one of our growth specialists at gardenpatch today! Or, better yet, delve into our expertly-authored ebook for unrivaled insights and tactics that will steer you towards success.

Stop Allowing Myths to Hold Back Your Brand

You can generate more leads and sales with the right strategy and tools. If you'd like to learn more about making this happen for your brand, gardenpatch can help you take the next steps toward a successful email marketing campaign!

Learn how to make email marketing work for your business. Talk to one of our growth specialists at gardenpatch today!


Popular Insights:

Tiago Headshot CTA Updated

Need Help with Your Email Marketing Strategy?



Subscribe by email